Simon, Garfunkel, Sanders, and Emotion in “America”: Political Ad Testing

By Aaron Reid
February 4, 2016
Bernie Sanders’ improbable rise in the Democratic primaries is a great example of the power of passion to motivate behavior.
By nearly pulling off a win in Iowa, and with the real possibility of winning New Hampshire looming next week, Sanders’ campaign illustrates the advantage inherent in standing on the shoulders of emotional messaging.
His campaign ad “America,” with Simon and Garfunkel’s song enhancing the subtext, provides a window into how he is evoking emotion based on values:

It is certainly a “feel good” ad. In fact, it is so obviously emotional, that the moderators of the last Democratic Town Hall decided it would be a good probe to use for a reaction from Hillary Clinton on the emotionality of Sanders’ campaign.
When put on the spot, Clinton handled the situation with great grace admitting that she “loved it” and applauding the “poetry” of it.

However, the impact of that ad on Hillary’s candidacy is not trifling. In the days leading into the Iowa primary, we tested the implicit impact of exposure to the Sanders’ “America” ad on emotional favorability toward Clinton.
The results showed something that a typical explicit question of voter preference might not have revealed.
Political Ad Testing Bernie Hillary Chart
To a remarkable degree, exposure to the Sanders’ ad sapped the emotional enthusiasm for Clinton’s candidacy among Iowa Democrats.
The challenge in advertising, for any brand, is to find the touch points that carry the greatest emotional weight within the target audience, and creatively execute with a compelling narrative.
Indeed, as we find time and time again, the key to social contagion of an idea, be it a commercial or political campaign, is the degree of emotion evoked among those who self-identify with your brand.
Be sure to check in next week to learn the emotional drivers behind the most viral ads from Super Bowl 50. And to learn more about implicit ad testing for your consumer brands or political campaigns, please reach out to us here.
Thanks to to Behavioral Scientist Dr. Nate Decker for his insight and collaboration on this study.
Ad Testing Consultation
  • Share Insight
Aaron Reid


Founder & CEO, Sentient Decision Science, Inc.

Examining Extremes

Examining Extremes

By Jeremy CloughJuly 2, 2020Anyone who’s spent significant time in consumer insights, decision science, or behavioral science has probably executed or commissioned a Choice-Based Conjoint (CBC) research project. But no one currently working in these...

Is Your Marketing Right for the Moment?

Is Your Marketing Right for the Moment?

By Jeremy CloughJune 12, 2020This informative webinar "Lay Low or Light It Up?" with Dr. Aaron Reid illustrates how testing the emotional impact of advertisements can help brands make sure their message is right for the moment. Dr. Reid highlights the...



For more information about Sentient Decision Science and our groundbreaking research please contact us.